BUILDING AN AI-FIRST CREATOR PLAYBOOK | PART 2: CREATIVITY & STORYTELLING

Qulture's six-part series on the new rules of creator strategy as shoppers turn to AI.


AI loves a second opinion. Give it three.

How role-based creator briefs impact AI visibility

We trust people for different reasons. We’re drawn to famous people, we listen to experts, and we believe friends who’ll tell us the truth. Creators earn our trust the same three ways. 

A review of 50 studies on social media influencers, published in November, found that all three kinds of trust are linked to people wanting to buy what a creator recommends. It turns out trusting people for different reasons matters to AI too. 

When brands hire creators for their voice, then hand them all the same brief, they shouldn’t be surprised when everything starts to sound the same. One brief to 12 creators results in the same story repeated 12 times. AI builds responses from what it finds online, creator posts included, so when those posts only tell one story, the brand may show up in fewer answers. Briefing creators by role, on the other hand, delivers consensus, something AI prioritizes across the different kinds of questions shoppers ask. 

At Qulture, we call these roles Stars, Experts, and Friends:

  • Stars (big names) carry the moment

  • Experts (specialists) carry the craft

  • Friends (honest reviewers) carry the verdict

One shared fact runs through all three. The Star names it, the Expert explains it, and the Friend tests it. Together, they answer what shoppers need to know, from browsing to buying.

IAB recently found that AI shoppers want creator input most for discovering products (32%), comparing options (31%), and finding the best value (38%). Each calls for a different story, and a different storyteller. Stars tell shoppers what’s new, Experts show how a product compares, and Friends say whether it’s worth the money.


Find your Stars, Experts, and Friends, and shape your AI answers. Email us and we’ll show you how AI responds to shoppers’ questions about your brand today, and where to close the gaps.

Stars make the news

When Alix Earle introduced Pantene’s anti-shedding line to her 8.2 million TikTok followers, she brought a story with it. “I felt like I started to lose my hair for the first time,” she told Who What Wear. A few weeks later, Glossy was writing about the launch.  

Stars can be the priciest voices you hire, and their posts often deliver what you pay for: reach and engagement. Interestingly, AI doesn’t seem to care how many followers a creator has. Later found no link between follower count and how often AI cites a creator, and 57% of the YouTube videos AI cites come from channels with fewer than 100,000 followers. What carries a Star’s moment into AI answers is the retelling. When shoppers ask AI what’s new, it reaches for the press. In Muck Rack’s analysis of 25 million AI citations, trend questions cited journalism in 46% of answers. So brief your Star for the post and for the story that editors will rush to retell.


Experts settle the argument

When Neutrogena built its Evenly Clear acne line, it brought in two dermatologists, Muneeb Shah and Dhaval Bhanusali, to help design it. Their work ran “from sharing formula insights to recommending ingredients,” Shah says. Order matters here. These specialists helped shape the product, so when it came time to talk about it, they had specifics to share, and specifics are what AI looks for. 

Research in Harvard Business Review found AI surfaces brands whose value it can read through “measurable attributes, structured product information, and credible third-party evidence.” A dermatologist explaining what 2% salicylic acid does gives AI a fact it can quote. So brief your Experts on the comparison shoppers make, with the numbers that settle it, and have them say those numbers on camera and put them in the title. AI can’t quote a vibe.


Friends get to say no

Creator Kelly Huang opened her video for beauty brand Refy the way a skeptic would. “I’m not gonna let you waste your money in this economy,” she told her 820,000 TikTok followers, “so let’s see if the new Refy skin tint is worth your coin.” Then she shared what the brand had emailed her: “We will pay you for your 100% honest opinion. Don’t need to see the video. Just go and post it.” Refy picked creators like her on purpose. The brand wanted people “who were going to give a genuine, honest review,” Refy’s head of brand, Charlotte Geoghegan, told Glossy.

Paying for a review you can’t see first sounds backward until you look at the research. The question AI shoppers most want creators to answer is whether a product is worth the money. That’s a Friend’s job, and it only works if the Friend is free to say no. In a University of Vienna experiment, young adults rated a creator’s negative review more helpful than a positive one, and it didn’t lower their intent to buy. So give your Friends the facts, step back, and let them tell shoppers who should skip it.

Fame, expertise, and honesty earn trust in different ways, and shoppers bring AI questions for each. A brief built for one kind of question leaves the rest unanswered. Hire each creator for what they do best, brief them for the questions they can answer, and let AI hear the whole lineup. This gives shoppers what they need to make a buying decision, and it gives AI what it needs to guide them.


Find your Stars, Experts, and Friends, and shape your AI answers. Email us and we’ll show you how AI responds to shoppers’ questions about your brand today, and where to close the gaps.

FAQ

Next
Next

Building an AI-first Creator Playbook | Part 1